Dovetail Jig "Shoot Out"

wpe3E8.jpg (15126 bytes)

   " Which is better, the "aaa jig" or the "bbb jig." I don't know how many times I am asked the question. If only there were an easy answer. There isn't. It can be a matter of price difference, "learning curve" difference, variability's of types of corners and spacing. A lot to compare and even then, there is a matter of personal preference. My preference is the jig that can let me do the very best dovetail without wasting precious wood. So, in the coming weeks, Beth, Gail and I will be using a number of jigs to make a library step stool.

  

     There are many jigs available. Here are the ones Beth and I will try: the Kehoe Jig — uses dovetail keys, Leigh Jig, Akeda, Incra, Woodhaven, LittleRat, Stots, Katie Jig, and we will even do one by hand using Frank Klaus' method.

wpe3E9.jpg (12958 bytes)

wpe3EA.jpg (13044 bytes)

   Our plan is to make one piece ten times — one dovetail jig per. I brought out a book that is a favorite of mine, and one that has a great library step stool as a project. I made three or four of these when I first got the book — in the early nineties. At that time, I made hand dovetails. The stools were made of cherry and looked great then — even nicer now.

  The book is very well illustrated. I have Beth make up a list of what we need for the first step stool. This one will be made of Birdseye maple because that is what I have. I probably will pick up some cherry for the rest of them.

wpe3EB.jpg (9843 bytes)

wpe3EC.jpg (14866 bytes)

    Beth starts by planing the two boards we will use for this step stool. The Birdseye maple is 2S2 and is flat. We want to smooth it up and bring it to 3/4" exactly. Beth has set the planer and is removing about 1/4 crank of the depth adjustment per pass. She could go considerably faster, but I want her to take it slow because of the figure in the boards.

    Beth marks where each of the cuts will be. One eight footer will give her the 4 pieces for the sides. The other board will give her enough for the steps.

wpe3ED.jpg (14083 bytes)
wpe3EE.jpg (17167 bytes)

    She has purposely added an inch to each piece so that the final cuts can be made at the table saw with the cabinetmaker's blade. We want the ends to be as good as we can make them. A good dovetailed corner starts with great ends.

     Each side is made up of two vertical members. Beth has cut the pieces and is now trying to find the best combinations.

wpe3EF.jpg (15594 bytes)
wpe3F0.jpg (10487 bytes)

   She marks the matching boards. The boards are relatively straight for 2S2 lumber but needs some jointing to make the seams strong and invisible.

  At the router table, she installs a 1/2" by 2" trim bit.

wpe3F1.jpg (12546 bytes)

                Main Menu  
                            To Dovetail Jig Shootout Menu                          

              Next Page